Light holiday reading on Midwestern Culture
Russ Feingold is the subject of a recent bio, Feingold: A New Democratic Party.
Here's what Salon writer Edward McClelland had to say while covering Russ's bio and throwing in plenty of provocation:
The upper Midwest -- specifically Wisconsin and its sister state, Minnesota -- has long seen itself as the conscience of America. Both states have a tradition of clean government and social reform, imported by German and Scandinavian immigrants. And both elect senators who, depending on your point of view, are either champions of progress or annoying liberal pains in the ass. Minnesota gave us Hubert Humphrey, Eugene McCarthy and Paul Wellstone. Wisconsin produced Gaylord Nelson, the founder of Earth Day, and Robert M. La Follette, one of the leading figures of the early 20th century progressive movement. La Follette steamed into Washington with a platform he called the Wisconsin Idea. Its planks included direct election of senators, state control of railroads, workmen's compensation, primary elections and a graduated income tax. Those were long-haired ideas in 1906, but thanks to Wisconsin, we now take them for granted.
La Follette was resented by his colleagues for "calling the roll" -- reading embarrassing votes to a senator's constituents -- and for casting one of six votes against World War I. Yet in 1957, the Senate named this virtuous crusader one of the five greatest solons in its history. La Follette is also Feingold's idol, we learn in Feingold: A New Democratic Party," a scrupulously admiring but shallow biography. Author Sanford D. Horwitt spent five years following Feingold to North Woods town meetings and interviewing family members, teachers, debate coaches and political allies. Horwitt, who grew up in Milwaukee, began this project as a Feingold booster, and can't seem to comprehend why anyone would dislike or disagree with the senator. Feingold's controversial style must have made him some enemies, but you won't find them interviewed here.
Particularly in the chapters on Feingold's boyhood in Janesville, Horwitt makes young Rusty sound like another Wisconsin character from the 1950s -- Richie Cunningham of "Happy Days." Rusty loved his mother's lemon meringue pie, and H-O-R-S-E in the driveway with his brother. In high school, where he was this "skinny dude everybody liked," he cruised the strip in Camaros and Chevelles, stopping for late-night burgers at the Oasis.
Talk about a game of narrative h-o-r-s-e... perhaps meant to look more like b-u-l-l.
Lots more to ponder, including a standoff between Russ and La Clinton - perfect for a sunny holiday weekend: a bit of history (find out about Sens. La Follette and Proxmire, Wisconsin/American giants) and a bit of gossip (' "You're not living in the real world," she shouted').
A lot of the fun is in detecting Ed's subtle sneer at Midwestern oddities, like bowling and Middleton; he shorts the history in Wisconsin of the death penalty, and then there's his borderline racist extrapolation of Wis politics, beginning: "Wisconsin loves a maverick, too. That helps explain why it sent La Follette and McCarthy to the Senate. (The other reason: Germans. They're fans of clean government, but they also fear Russians.)"
I think it's possible that this hagiography is timed to gin up groundswell for a McCain-Feingold ticket. Ed think's it was in hopes of a renewed Feingold campaign, but Russ hasn't waivered since shutting that down in 2006. McCain's short list for veeps only came out recently; this book was out in February.
There are some great lines, like this one: "What's more, the Senate can always use a pain in the ass. Thanks to Wisconsin, it usually gets one. "
Enjoy!

